Subject: Re: Copy of the Acceptance letter for ICISP 2006 / ICDT 2006
From: conf
Date: Tue, 16 May 2006 11:45:15 +0200
To: Emin Gabrielyan

At 10:30 16/05/2006 +0200, Emin Gabrielyan wrote:
Please instruct how to access the comments of the reviewers

"First, please consider the reviewers' comments or guidelines when editing your final version. ... Again, please accurately consider the review comments when finalizing your camera ready version. The chairs will check for the conformance with the reviewers' comments."



relevance originality content presentation summary competence
4 (4=good) 4 (4=good) 4 (4=good) 4 (4=good) 4 (4=good) 3 (3=high)Comments to Authors

This paper introduces a capillary routing algorithm and compares
it with

the existing algorithms in terms of ROR. The paper is overall well
written and has sufficient novelty for publication.
relevance originality content presentation summary competence
5 (5=excellent) 4 (4=good) 4 (4=good) 5 (5=excellent) 5 (5=excellent) 3 (3=high)Comments to Authors

The paper could be shortened.


Title should be changed since the routing schemes are applicable to any
real-time media streaming, not just voice.
Comments to TPC only:

The paper proposes, develops, and analyzes "capillary"
routing with

forward error correction for media streaming. The paper is well written,
well organized, and makes a tangible research contribution.  The
contribution has practical applications.  I recommend that this paper be
accepted.
Title should be changed since the routing schemes are applicable to any
real-time media streaming, not just voice.
relevance originality content presentation summary competence
5 (5=excellent) 5 (5=excellent) 5 (5=excellent) 4 (4=good) 4 (4=good) 2 (2=Medium)Comments to Authors

The explanation of capillary routing in section 4 is a bit
confusing.


It would be useful if the authors assesed how long it takes for the
algorithm to converge with respect to link failures / changes.
An additional assesment on how easy it is from a technoeconomical
viewpoint to include capillary routing in current routers would be
helpful.
Thanks
Emin

conf wrote:

On behalf of the Program Committee, we are happy to inform you that your paper has been accepted for publication and presentation at the co-located events ICISP 2006 or ICDT 2006.

The acceptance of your paper is made with the understanding that each accepted paper will be registered and at least one author will attend the conference to present the paper (preferably with PowerPoint slides).

First, please consider the reviewers' comments or guidelines when editing your final version.

The Proceedings are published by the IEEE Computer Society Press. Please read carefully the "Manuscript Preparation Instructions" on the conference web site when submitting the final version. All the registration related issues must be addressed to oana@vicov.com.

Note that a paper will be published on the IEEE Xplore and Conference Proceedings only after the paper is registered, i.e., the registration form is sent in the due time and successfully processed. Please fax the registration for before uploading the paper. the hotel booking can be sent later, using the same registration form. However, as there is a hot season, please book the conference hotel as soon as possible; on May 20 our contractors must release the pre-booked extra rooms.

The registration form is available from the conference web site: see 
"Registration form"

A registered attendee for an event, has access to all sessions of the collocated event, as a bonus. However, each paper must be separately registered.

The deadline for the submission of registration forms to the organizers is 20 May 2006. Otherwise, the paper is considered withdrawn and it will neither appear in the proceedings of the conference nor published on the IEEE site. You can still update the originally and timely submitted paper on the IEEE site later on, as shown in "Manuscript Preparation Instructions"

Thanking once again for your active participation, we are looking forward for your cooperation to successfully finalize the event.

Again, please accurately consider the review comments when finalizing your camera ready version.
The chairs will check for the conformance with the reviewers' comments.

Please fill the registration form as soon as possible. Flight information can be sent later, using the same registration form.

Sincerely yours,
Events's Chairs